South Carolina Supreme Court Upholds BZA decision on Telecom Tower Siting Finding the Board Acted on Competent Evidence

On April 2, 2013, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

In 2006, the Town of Mount Pleasant (“the Town”) rezoned property on Whipple Road adjacent to the Candlewood residential subdivision from an R-1 residential zone to an Economic Development zone.  The property was owned by South Carolina Electric and Gas, and leased to SCANA Communications, which hoped to build a telecommunications tower there.  In an […]

KY Appeals Court Uphold Commission Decision Permitting Cell Tower Based on Substantial Evidence

On March 15, 2013, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

Pegasus Tower Company sought to construct a 152.5-foot monopole cellular tower in Louisville, Kentucky, on property owned by Village Manor Properties, adjacent to property owned by appellant, Masonic Homes of Kentucky, Inc. In accordance with Kentucky law, Pegasus submitted a uniform application to construct the tower to the Louisville Metro Planning Commission, which held a [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in NJ Finds Borough’s Denial of Variances for Wireless Facilities Violates the TCA

On January 25, 2013, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

In order for its signal to reach customers, T-Mobile built cell sites in various locations to maximize wireless service. Due to a significant gap in coverage in the Borough of Leonia, T-Mobile applied for a use variance in order to place an antenna and other equipment on the roof of an apartment building. This building, [...]

N.J. Appellate Court Finds Town Invalidly Denied Tower Variances

On November 6, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

New York SMSA, doing business as Verizon Wireless (hereinafter “Verizon”), planned on constructing a 130 foot monopole telecommunications tower within the Township of Colts Neck.  Verizon sought zoning variances from the Zoning Board of Adjustment of Colts Neck (hereinafter “ZBA”), but was denied.  Verizon appealed the denial to the Superior Court of New Jersey, Law [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in NY finds Aesthetics Sufficient to Deny Cell Tower Application

On October 25, 2012, in Current Caselaw - New York, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

T-Mobile Northeast instituted this action to challenge the denial of their special use permit application.  Specifically, T-Mobile asserts the Town of Islip violated the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (hereinafter “TCA”) and Article 78 of the New York Civil Procedure Law and Rules.  In this opinion, the United States District Court, Eastern District of New York [...]

Fed. Dist. CT in PA finds Denial of Application to Construct Cell Tower a Violation of the TCA

On October 8, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

Hamilton Township, Pennsylvania, denied Global Tower’s application to construct a cell tower.  Global Tower challenged this denial in federal court, alleging violations of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (hereinafter “TCA”).  Upon review of the magistrate judge’s recommendations, the United States District Court, Middle District of Pennsylvania granted Global Tower’s motion for summary judgment, and in [...]

NC Appeals Court Upholds Denial of Special Use Permit for Communications Tower

American Towers sought to construct a communication tower in the industrial management zone district.  In this zone district, communication towers are permitted by way of special use permit.  To obtain a special use permit, the party must submit an application and satisfy six general requirements and twenty additional tower related requirements.  Upon review, Morrisville denied [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in FL Holds PUD Governing Documents Do Not Permit Cell Towers

On July 4, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

New Cingular Wireless sought to construct a cellular telephone tower in the Benjamin’s Run Planned Unit Development (PUD) in the City of Tallahassee, Florida.  City officials had sought the guidance of a state administrative law judge on the issue of whether a cellular telephone tower was authorized under the PUD’s governing document.  After holding an [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in Maryland Upholds Board’s Denial of Conditional Use Permit for Communications Tower Since it was Based on Substantial Evidence under the TCA of 1996

On June 4, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

To close the significant gap in service coverage occurring in the area “along Burntwoods Road, Danmark Drive, Sharp Road, Roscommon Drive and Hobbs Road, as well as in the developed surrounding residential neighborhoods,” in 2009, the plaintiff, T-Mobile, submitted a conditional use petition to the Howard County Hearing Authority, to build a commercial communications tower [...]

4th Circuit Court of Appeals Finds Denial of Permit for Wireless Communications Tower Not Based on Substantial Evidence

On May 8, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

T-Mobile received complaints about a gap in coverage in the area of Newport News, Virginia, and identified R.O Nelson Elementary School as a target location for a new wireless communication tower.  Under the local zoning ordinance, construction of the tower required a conditional use permit to be issued.  In April 2008, T-Mobile submitted an application [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in NY Finds ZBA Denial of Wireless Facility Violates both Federal and State Law and Orders Approval of Variance

On April 30, 2012, in Current Caselaw - New York, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

AT&T, a telecommunications provider, discovered a coverage gap in the town of Fenton, New York.  To remedy the gap, AT&T proposed construction of a cellular phone tower and applied for a use variance.  AT&T submitted affidavits from several experts along with the result of a “balloon test.”  For the balloon test, AT&T raised a large [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in NY Overturn’s Board’s Denial of Special Use Permit Under Telecommunications Act

On April 24, 2012, in Current Caselaw - New York, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

Verizon Wireless, a telecommunications carrier, is considered a public utility for purposes of zoning.  Verizon identified a “coverage gap” in its services in the Village of Flora Park and sought to construct a telecommunications facility on the roof of a commercial building to resolve the coverage problem.  Since the village code provided that any “antenna [...]

Fed. Dist. Court in NY Says TCA Does Not Cover Regulation of Wireless Internet Access Facility

On April 10, 2012, in Current Caselaw - New York, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

Clearwire, an entity of Sprint, provides wireless broadband for Sprint in Nassau County, New York.  Clearwire applied to the Village of Lynbrook for a special use permit to build a telecommunications facility on the top of an existing building to provide 4G to the area.  After several public hearings, the Board denied Clearwire’s special use [...]

4th Circuit Court of Appeals Upholds Denial of Wireless Facility Finding Board Did Not Violate Substantial Evidence Provision of the TCA

On April 9, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

New Cingular Wireless (“AT&T”) sought approval from the Fairfax, Virginia board to build an eighty-eight foot telecommunications tower in a residential area.  Under the county’s zoning ordinance, a telecommunications tower may only be built in residential areas with a special exception and approval of a site plan by the planning commission.  The planning commission must [...]

4th Circuit Court of Appeals Upholds Denial of Permit for Wireless Facility Finding no Violation of the TCA

On March 27, 2012, in Current Caselaw, Land Use, Law of the Land, Wireless Communications, by Patricia Salkin

T-Mobile had sought approval from Fairfax County, Virginia officials to construct a wireless service facility on a utility pole which already housed similar equipment for two other competing wireless companies – AT&T and Verizon.  The proposal, which involved increasing the height of the pole from 100 to 110 feet and installing a cylindrical configuration of [...]

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Our Clients and Partners

Get the Flash Player to see the slideshow.